Thursday, June 25, 2009

Nice try, Eric

Who mentions my work on the AFR on Pharyngula (see comment 51) and gets one response back referring to Carrier's critique. Perhaps a casual reader of Internet Infidels might not know about my own published counter-critique in Baggett and Walls ed. C. S. Lewis as a Philosopher (IVP, 2008), (and in a couple of other places as well) but surely must have seen Darek Barefoot's response on Infidels?

11 comments:

Ilíon said...

VR: "... Internet Infidels ..."

Ir, as I call it: Invincible Ignorance (disregarding that 'invincible ignorance' is a technical term which means something quite different than I mean).

Victor Reppert said...

If you are in invincible ignorance, it's not your fault.

Ilíon said...

"... (disregarding that 'invincible ignorance' is a technical term which means something quite different than I mean)."

legodesi said...

I was deeply saddened reading down the comments.

Shackleman said...

I was downright disgusted both with Mr. Myers and when reading down the comments. And, not to be maudlin, but I was also deeply concerned for the future of our society. This is what they're teaching in our universities these days? This militant hatred, vulgarity, intolerance, and vitriol?

(Word Verification for this post: esessess -- Amusing.)

Ilíon said...

I've had "esessess" a couple of times recently.

Victor Reppert said...

Thank God this is not a sycophantic echo chamber here.

Is this free thought?

Ilíon said...

Truly deep thought doesn't need to echo.

Victor Reppert said...

Mega dittos, Ilion.

Ilíon said...

Well, a little reverberation now and again surely isn't amiss. ;-)

Martin Gamble said...

Dangerous Idea is one of the best blogs that I've ever read.