I am wondering what your response is to the Bayesian calculation that I gave would be.
H1) Humans are constructed by God is such a way that they can be fulfilled only in relationship to God.
H2) It is not the case that humans are constructed by God in such a way that they can be fulfilled only in relationship to God. This can be true if atheism is true, or if God doesn't care,
D= the existence of "heavenly" desires
Now, notice I don't need the claim that these desires couldn't arise through evolution. In fact, as I did the calcuations, it's 70% likely that these desire would arise through evolution, and the calculation still works!
Now doesn't it seem to you that D is more likely given H1 than H2?