Friday, April 11, 2008

Why Calvinists Can't Solve The Problem of Evil

I'm going to redate the old post, but I'm fixing the argument from evil to leave out the stuff about the best of all possible worlds.

The title here suggests that Arminians (or maybe universalists) can solve the problem of evil, and maybe that's something I don't want to imply. However, I am going to argue that while the theist has some hope of providing a rebuttal to the argument from evil if Calvinism is false, the theist who is as Calvinist is thoroughly embarrassed in the face of the atheist argument.

Let's look at the atheist argument from evil. The argument goes as follows:

1. God, if God exists, is omniscient, omnipotent, and perfectly good.
2. If there is a God, then there is no unnecessary evil.
3. But there is unnecessary evil.
4. Therefore God does not exist.

Now a lot of responses to the problem of evil employ two themes. One of those themes is that many evils in the world are not caused by God, but are the result of God's allowing creatures to act freely. If God makes us free to commit murder or not to commit murder, then God cannot guarantee that we not commit murder. Second, some things that seem evil from a temporal, present-day perspective may not be evils from an eternal perspective. So, for example, it may seem to me to be an evil that I have a certain health problem, but from God may see that there are elements of character that will improve within me if I suffer from this health problem.

The problem with Calvinism is that on the Calvinistic view God sovereignly determines the outcome of every action. And there are situations which persevere into eternity which very clearly could have been better. In particular, "Smith's going to hell" is a situation which goes preseveres into eternity and is not going to get better.

Consider what philosopher Douglas Jesseph calls "The World of Mr. Rogers."
In the world of Mr. Rogers, it's all a big happy neighborhood and everyone does what is right, and then go to heaven when they die. This world is obviously a better world than this one. Just ask anyone who has gone to hell and see if they wouldn't prefer the World of Mr. Rogers.

Do creatures in the World of Mr. Rogers act freely? If you accept the Compatibilist theory of Free Will, then they do. The Compatibilist points out that there is a difference between doing what you want to do, and doing what you don't want to do. You act unfreely if you are dragged in chains back to your jail cell. You act freely if you are listening to your favorite CD, playing your favorite game, watching your favorite movie, etc. When your actions and your desires match up, you are acting freely. If your actions and desires don't match, then you aren't.

Now suppose you have the desires that you are caused to have. God arranges it so that you always want to do the right thing. God controls your desires and then gives you the freedom, that is the power, to act out those desires.

Given this theory of free will, it is easy to see that God could still give us free will and nevertheless still be able to create the World of Mr. Rogers, where no one sins and no one goes to hell. If Calvinism is true, then that is exactly the kind of free will that God has granted us. Calvinists will often say that God has every right to punish us for our sins because, after all, it is not the case that we wanted to do the right thing and were forced against our will to do the wrong thing. Rather, we did what we wanted to do, even though we were predestined to do it.

Is the World of Mr. Rogers boring? Well, if it's boring, then heaven will be boring too, because heaven is supposed to be a sin-free zone.

The simple fact is that if Calvinism is true, then God could have created the World of Mr. Rogers, but sovereignly chose not to. Why?

At this point it is possible to now appeal to human limitations, either limitations in human knowledge or in human goodness. Even though we can't see that this world is better than the WMR, it really is better, even though some people are damned in this world and no one is damned in WMR.
I think these arguments from the limits of our knowledge have more force where the final outcome is unknown or inadequately understood. We know the final outcome in both worlds. Everyone is happy in the WMR and everyone gets saved. Many people suffer in our world and some are lost.

Another way of replying is to present a version of Paul's rebuttal from the Book of Romans, "Who are you, o man, to answer back to God?" Now if this is a version of the argument from the limitations of our knowledge, which I think it is, then it has some value, but not on a Calvinistic scenario. If however, it is a way of simply dismissing the argument from evil, it is a transparently question-begging argument. The AfE questions whether there is a God, that is, a being omnisicent, omnipotent, and perfectly good, to answer back to. We cannot assume that such a being exists in order to eliminate the question as to whether or not an OOP being exists.

But why would God want to give us any kind of free will other than the kind of free will that the compatibilist (and the Calvinist) is prepared to admit? The incompatiblist holds that human beings have the kind of freedom that is incompatible with our acting from a determining cause. If we sin, we could have done otherwise under the actual circumstances.

Consider a Star Trek I once saw. There was a man, who in the show was named Flint, who was born several thousand years BC, whose body was able to regenerate whenever it was damaged, granting him an virtually endless life. What that meant was that, over and over again, he saw his companions and wives die. He ended up on a planet in outer space where he decided to build the perfect companion, an android named Rayna. Rayna could converse with him on any subject imaginable, could be physically affectionate, but there was one problem. Its "love" for Flint was fully and completely determined by Flint's programming, and therefore was deficient as love. So Flint brought the Enterprise and Captain Kirk to the planet so that he could be a rival for Rayna's affections. (Captain Kirk was, in more ways than one, modeled after President John F. Kennedy--JTK, JFK. Say no more.) Anyway, since Rayna was an android, Rayna couldn't choose freely, and so fell over and became deactivated.

If God is love, then isn't there something deficient about love that is fully and completely determined by the one who recevies the love? If this is the case, then there is a good reason why a loving God might choose to give us incompatiblist freedom, even if this freedom results in sin and perhaps even eternal separation from God for some persons.

26 comments:

Jason Pratt said...

Don't have time to leave any detailed comments (or criticisms) myself; but I will say: good article, and good comments from others (including rak and David.)

Drew said...

"If this is the case, then there is a good reason why a loving God might choose to give us incompatiblist freedom, even if this freedom results in sin and perhaps even eternal separation from God for some persons."

Even if God gave this "freedom," and created, then by doing so He is choosing to create beings headed for Hell. The only difference between this theory and Calvinism is that in your theory, Almighty God is powerless or unwilling to do anything about those who do not "choose" Him. In Calvinism, and in the Bible, no one chooses God, not even one. Out of his love and for the excellence of His Name, God calls some to Himself.

Your way, God creates sinners but then is helpless to save them. In the Bible, understood in Calvinism, God weaves a plan to display His perfect grace, perfect wrath, perfect power, and glory forever.

God is sovereign; He will do as He pleases. That is the glory of being God.

Anonymous said...

Even the title is possibly a fallacy. A Calvinist (which I am very much so) need not solve a non-existent problem. The problem of evil is only a problem to someone willing to question the authority of God's revelation. If you presuppose (as I do) that the Bible solves the problem of evil in the person Jesus Christ, then the need to have another solution is gone. God does not have to conform to our reasoning. What we call a problem may be quite different to what He does and He is right.
If I were to say to you there is the problem of wrinkles in shirts on Sunday morning, only my wife would say it must be solved, but not I. In that framework - she would win regardless of my ability to reason.
In the realm of good and evil, God decides the fundamental meaning of those terms and all of their nuance. I often say that words like life, love and joy are God's to define and not Webster or Roget. We put too much stock in our reasoners and not enough in God's Book. - Thanks for the discussion - I dig chess too by the way. I don't think Fischer is resting in Peace.

Nesalem. Vital de Andrés said...

It's all predestined, therefore in God's mind everything is in its right place within eternity. Our contingent existence isn't really so: whatever we do is right and correct to God because is done according to his eternal disign.

Calvinism taken into its extreme leads into the zen satori: my life is an ever present in God's mind. Nothing I do is defective, nothing is missing. I live an eternal transparency.

Ilíon said...

How is the assumption/premise that the world contains unnecessary evil justified?

Of course, assumptions (strictly speaking) cannot be proven.

However, the nature of this particular assumption/premise of the argument indicates that, strictly speaking, it should be understood as being a conclusion of some prior argument.


So, how do we *know* there is unnecessary evil in the world? Or, if we don't know this, we can hardly use the assertion as a premise of this current argument.

Ilíon said...

VR: "... Do creatures in the World of Mr. Rogers act freely? If you accept the Compatibilist theory of Free Will, then they do. The Compatibilist points out that there is a difference between doing what you want to do, and doing what you don't want to do. You act unfreely if you are dragged in chains back to your jail cell. You act freely if you are listening to your favorite CD, playing your favorite game, watching your favorite movie, etc. When your actions and your desires match up, you are acting freely. If your actions and desires don't match, then you aren't."

But, of course, if you are being dragged in chains back to your cell, you are not acting. You are being acted upon.

Error said...

Hi Dr. Reppert,

I responded to your other post where you critique some of my comments. I thought I;d respond to this one too

http://triablogue.blogspot.com/2008/04/why-reppert-cant-unsolve-calvinists.html

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

格安航空券domestic air tickets to the tour, if ESUTORABERUINTANASHONARU cheap airline tickets, cheap domestic flights, domestic flights, cheap airline tickets, domestic tour site. Tokyo (Haneda) and selling cheap airline tickets! Cheap airline tickets for domestic professional staff will offer you a plan.SAIDOBIJINESU ドロップシッピング, wind,GITAI net in the business side to side business, starting with no risk UINDOSHIPPINGU Drop it! Wind from the side to the left to please Dropshipping.

Anonymous said...

Certainly, wow goldthere was no physical wow golddefect. By its perfect shape, wow goldits vigour, and its natural dexterity in the use of all its untried limbs, wow goldthe infant was worthy to have been brought forth in Eden; worthy to have been left there,to be the plaything of the angels after theworld's first parents were driven out. wow goldThe child had a native grace which does not invariably coexist with faultless beauty; its attire, however simple, always impressed the beholder as if it were the very garb that precisely became it best. wow goldBut little Pearl was not clad in rustic weeds. Her mother, with a morbid purpose that may be better understood hereafter,wow gold had bought the richest tissues that could be procured, and allowed her imaginative faculty its full play in the arrangement and decoration of the dresses which the child wore, before the public eye.

Anonymous said...

15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24

Anonymous said...

sell wow gold
[url=http://www.112nvir.com]sell wow gold[/url]

Anonymous said...

你了解网络游戏吗. 2009最新网络游戏 ?中国的网络游戏最早开始于2001年. 策略类游戏 网络游戏分类很广. 策略小游戏 有免费的. 策略游戏 有收费的. 策略游戏下载 有休闲类的,有格斗类的. 大游戏 有3D的. 即时战略 有2D的.在2008年未. 即时战略游戏 策略类游戏-战神不败开始公测.在万人的战斗中. 免费网游 指挥的智慧直接影响着战局的走向. 免费在线游戏 是迂加突袭. 魔兽sf 还是围魏救赵. 魔兽世界单机版 是火烧百里. 小游戏 还是擒贼?一切由你做主. 永久免费网游 !一场大规模的网络游戏开始上演. 战略游戏 那就是战神不败. 战神2 这是一款终身免费的网络游戏. 战神世界 以殖民战争为主题的策略类游戏(简称SLG)――玩家通过指挥官来建造建筑. 战争类游戏 编练部队. 战争游戏 升级科研以发展个人和公会势力,并借助战争与殖民者不断开拓势力范围. 最好玩的网游 夺取资源. 最新免费网游 最终战胜敌对玩家. 取得游戏的胜利.

Anonymous said...

I haven't been playing all. burning crusade cd that much World of Warcraft recently. burning crusade cd key But I've been logging on occasionally. burning crusade key to do things like Shadowcloth . buy wow account and alchemy transmutes. cheap account and to put things. key wotlk on the auction house Or playing short bursts. lich king doing a few daily . lich wow quests I've also been cleaning. lich wow up my inventories for example selling the . need wow metal bars and gems . serial wow I had stored for jewelcrafting. world of warcraft cd keys All that accumulated. wow account a lot of gold. wow account europe and this weekend I. wow accounts had the 5,200 gold. wow burning crusade key for my third epic flying. wow cd key mount together So now my mage . wow cd keys joins my priest and my warrior. wow characters in having an epic flyer. wow key Not immediately useful on release but as I'll probably. wow key level the mage to 77 before . wow keys I do the warrior (if ever). wow of the lich king I wanted. wow wrath of lich king the mage to have that mount. wrath king So, cleaning up inventory . wrath lich king and buying an epic flying mount. wrath of lich king are definitely . wrath of the lich on my list of things to cheap cell phonesdo in preparation for. wrath of the lich king wow Wrath of the Lich King.

Anonymous said...

As always. 8GB MP3 PLAYER, a great big Thank . buy cheap wow gold. You to the WoW Insider editors. carte wow. for allowing us to. cd key. publish this movie both here . cheap world of warcraft gold. and on our little blog. clé cd. at the same time. compte wow. !dear big red kitty:. free online war games, i think i love you. gold wow, your videos and commentary. karte wow. are teh awesome. mp3 player. i watch every one. play war games. and enjoy them tremendously. world of warcraft buy gold. i don't even play a hunter. wotlk. and most of the time. wotlk. i have no clue what. wow acc, you are talking about. wow account. but i don't care. wow authentication. i've said it before. wow card. but i wish all warcraft videos. wow compte. were done this way. wow europe, please keep 'em coming. wow gold, Alas. wow gold. wow gold. wow gold kaufen.. my dreams were. wow kaufen, shattered as I attempted to tame . wow oro, the beast only to cell phone accessoriesbe greeted with an error. wrath of lich king, instead of scrolling hearts.

Unknown said...

SEO対策(けんさくエンジンさいてきか)とは、ある特定の検索エンジンを対象として検索結果でより上位に現れるようにウェブページを書き換えること。またそ の技術。サーチエンジン最適化とも言われる。英語の "Search Engine Optimization" の頭文字を取ってSEOとも言われる。最適化の対象になる検索エンジンは、Googleであることが多い。これは、海外(特にアメリカ)において Googleのシェアが高いことによる。日本ではYahoo!サーチの利用者が多いため、Yahoo!サーチ対策も重視されている。

Anonymous said...

138 164 169 http://mucho.dtiblog.com/ k042 AUC T XR0 XR1 Go100 http://gftnc.seesaa.net/ http://gongonzou.seesaa.net/ http://maruta.be/marumaru00

Best World of Warcraft Gold Guide said...

great post man :)

Anonymous said...

税理士 顧問料
運転免許 合宿
ボイストレーニング
ED治療
施主支給
住まい リフォーム
補助金
まつげ エクステ
IELTS
ミセス
婦人靴
苗木
タオル
代理店
電話代行
介護フランチャイズ
エステ
税理士
インプラント
パワーストーン
時計買取
M&A
債務整理
異業種交流パーティー
たるみ
一戸建て
公式サイト
ウォーキング
調布 不動産
ノーリツ
カナダ留学
アンテナ工事
飲食店開業
Yシャツ セット
池袋 賃貸
CSR
ブライダルエステ
バイク便 東京
マンツーマン 英会話
英会話 新宿
英会話 レッスン
IHCWAY
ハーレー

Unknown said...

模式探行杭州特价机票买票脑残调查
推广门户杭州搬家公司在搬家电子
生活网站推广上海私家侦探模式一
排上搜索结婚钻戒特价买票
优化从事Google排名生活需要
电子侦网站推广业业
模式排上杭州网站建设、杭州网页设计业第

jimmychooshoes said...

mcqueen shoes
alexander mcqueen heels
Alexander McQueen Store
Jimmy Choo sale
Replica jimmy choo shoes
manolo blahnik online store
manolo shoes
manolo blahnik sale
replica christian louboutin shoes
discount christian louboutin shoes
alexander mcqueen shoes
jimmy choo outlet
jimmy choos
jimmy shoes
Manolo Blahnik Shoes
christian shoes



Alexander McQueen Geometric leather

pumps

Alexander McQueen Band leather

sandals

Anonymous said...

風俗
東京 風俗
渋谷 風俗
上野 風俗
池袋 風俗
新宿 風俗
五反田 風俗
品川 風俗
新橋 風俗
錦糸町 風俗
中野 風俗
立川 風俗
神奈川 風俗
横浜 風俗
川崎 風俗
埼玉 風俗
大宮 風俗
西川口 風俗

nikeairmaxshoe said...

Even if, in the beginning, the requirement was generally concentrated within the East Coast previous your USA
From here, Nike Outlets ,
the acceptance of air blood flow pressure one went up by continually.
2011 Cheap Nike Air Max Online Store air blood flow pressure one carried its accomplishment out in to the whole world.and made it especially . the most effective durability in , glorious dynasty, nike air blood flow max 2011 women's only to become opened you range the.
Nike Air Max Shoes Knight through the full procedure by way of the business chain happen to be adjusted, especially stock manage strategy as well as
overseas gross sales
system.provide low-cost Nike air blood flow pressure 1, price drop Nike air blood event boots and shoes appeared Tonglu,
May 26, one precise
the world's largest embroidered big
Christian Louboutin Outlet
lengthy 2.8 meters great and 0.87 meters, 0.71 meters better and weighs 63 kg, boots and shoes is regularly tremendous to lie straight down in several
to three people,Abercrombie Fitch UK,
2011 women's
only Abercrombie & Fitch Clothes
your condition unique container support cost-effective and practical, crafts.the most effective durability in , glorious dynasty, nike air blood flow max 2011 women's only Christian Louboutins Discount to become opened you range the. Knight through the full procedure by way of the business chain happen to be adjusted, especially stock manage strategy as well as overseas gross sales system.

Nike soccer cleats said...

Said was wonderful, really the best site! Liked by the way best described 2011 Nike soccer cleats.Prefer the Nike mercurial soccer cleats

luck said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ADMIN said...

VIPQIUQIU99.COM AGEN JUDI DOMINO ONLINE TERPERCAYA DI INDONESIA