Looking at the Socratic Club record, it looks as if Lewis had
memorable exchanges with four notable philosophers: C. E. M. Joad, H. H. Price,
A. J. Ayer, and Elizabeth Anscombe. The responses to Joad and Price are found
in God in the Dock. The exchange with
Ayer was in response to Ayer’s harsh critique of a paper by Michael Foster in
which Lewis took up Foster’s defense. In addition to these exchanges at the
Oxford Socratic Club, there was also the response by Lewis to a critique of his
paper on the humanitarian theory of punishment by the Australian philosopher J.
J. C. Smart. It need not be concluded that Lewis won all the other exchanges, although
Joad subsequently converted to Christianity and credited Lewis with playing an
important role in his conversion. But none of the other exchanges with
philosophers could reasonably thought of the kind of resounding defeat the
Anscombe exchange is portrayed as being. Had Lewis been as incompetent as his
is sometimes portrayed as being, it would not have taken an Anscombe to wipe
the floor with him; Joad, Price, and Ayer would have done so as well.
No comments:
Post a Comment