Monday, December 10, 2012

The Three Parts of Morality

A redated post.

The Three Parts of Morality
Book 3, Chapter 1

“There is a story of a schoolboy who was asked what he thought God was like. He replied that, as far as he could make out, God was the sort of person who is always snooping round to see if anyone is enjoying himself and then trying to stop it.”

By contrast, “Moral rules are rules for running the human machine.” They are, to use my example, the instructions in the owner’s manual of a car, that tells you to keep the oil level up in the car and to change the oil every 3000 miles. These rules may seem at first to go against our natural inclinations.

Should we speak of moral ideals instead of moral rules? If we think of them is ideals rather than rules, then different people might have higher or lower ideals. Everyone is expected to try to follow the rules, even though no one comes close to following them perfectly.

Lewis mentions two ways in which “the human machine” goes wrong. One way is by bad relationships amongst people. The other is when things go wrong within the individual. Much discussion about morality on the part of modern people has to do with how people should relate to one another; that it is wrong to cause harm to others. He compares the moral life to a fleet of ships. The fleet may fail because of internal failures within the ships, or may fail because they drift apart or collide with one another.

But there is a third component to our moral lives. Are the ships going where they ought to be going? They may work well internally and sail in formation, and yet not get to the right place. Of course this means that there is a proper goal for human life.

So that means morality means:

1) Fair play among human beings.
2) Harmonizing the person internally.
3) Fulfilling the purpose of human life.

Modern people think of 1) and do not think of 2) and 3). They say “There can’t be anything wrong with it if it doesn’t harm anybody.”

2) is a moral tradition that goes back to Plato. According to Plato, reason (the desire for the Form of the Good) should command, and spirit (the interpersonal self), and appetite obey.

3. Is a tradition that goes back to Aristotle. The good life is the life that fulfils human nature. It assumes that human life has an inherent purpose. For Aristotle that purpose is inherent in our nature as humans, for the Christian tradition it is given to us by God.

Lewis thinks that we should pay more attention to 2 and 3. “You cannot make men good by law: and without good men you cannot have a good society.

Christianity is a set of claims that, if true, will profoundly affect how we ought to behave.

Christianity teaches that I am a creature created by God for God’s purpose. Do I simply belong to myself? Many people think we do. If there is no God, then we own essentially belong to ourselves. “Whose life is it anyway?” So if we want, for example, to commit suicide, all we need to consider is what it would do to others. “If someone else made me, then I shall have a lot of duties which I should not have if I simply belonged to myself.

Suppose I am addicted to video games. “It doesn’t hurt anybody,” I say. But am I fulfilling my nature as a human being?

Immanuel Kant thought that it was wrong to lie, first and foremost, because our capacity to speak was given to us in order to speak the truth, in lying we damage ourselves by using a facility for something for which it was not intended. In fact, he maintained that all lies were wrong, something thought by most people to be too strong a position. But the emphasis on this motivation for truthfulness is something Lewis would approve of.

Christianity also teaches that human beings last forever. This has two implications:

1) States of character are more important than particular actions. If my bad temper is getting worse, this may not be a big deal if we feed the worms after 70 years. If I go on forever, then my bad temper will be just hell until it is corrected. “Hell is the precisely correct term what it would be.”
2) If individuals are gone after 70 years then a state, a nation, or a civilization may last for a thousand years. (Hitler, for example, promised that the Third Reich would last for a thousand years.) But if Christianity is true, then an individual is more important than a civilization.

Lewis says that from here on he will give an account of morality with the assumption that Christianity is true. Although this is an apologetic work, Lewis is content simply to give an analysis of what ethics looks like on Christian assumptions, without feeling the need to prove the truth of Christianity first. It attempts to answer the question “Can we get sensible answers to moral questions if we adopt a Christian viewpoint.”


ozero91 said...

This stuff reminds me of Andrews' new Moral argument. It's better than Craig's IMO.

unkleE said...

Yeah, good stuff. But I think Lewis and you make one small mistake - "Christianity also teaches that human beings last forever."

I wonder where the Bible teaches this? I read that we are dust and to dust we will return, and that the wicked will be "destroyed". Our only hope is resurrection of our very mortal bodies, and only then can we take on immortality.

This makes an enormous difference.

Unknown said...

Unkle, does John 5:28-29 make a difference.

unkleE said...

"Unkle, does John 5:28-29 make a difference."

Hi TJA, no I don't think it does. I think we have to be a little wary of claiming to know too much about these things. The teaching I suggested is too pervasive to ignore, and one can easily fit in this passage by remembering that John in Revelation talks about "the second death".

Steve Lovell said...

I'm remain impressed by this part of Lewis. The much forgotten third part of morality is less forgotten now, as Alasdair MacIntyre reminded us about it in his seminal work _After Virtue_.

His thesis was that morality originally had the following three parts:

(1) The human condition. Man as he is.
(2) The telos. The purpose of man's existence. Man as he should be. Lewis's third part of morality.
(3) Morality, which gets you from the first to the second.

With moderns having jetisoned the telos, MacIntyre maintained that the remaining two parts couldn't be made to fit together.

Still seems right to me.

B. Prokop said...


If you don't care for John 5:28-29, how about Mark 12:24-27? Or all of First Corinthians Chapter 15?

Or if you are a Catholic and have all 73 books in your Bible, turn to Wisdom 3:1-8.

Maths Tutor Wirral said...

'Christianity teaches that I am a creature created by God for God’s purpose'

Well, you are not.

If you like, I can tell you how you got created.

Just do a google search on 'human reproduction'.

W.LindsayWheeler said...

Actually, this statement: Christianity also teaches that human beings last forever. is wrong!

It was Plato that taught that the soul is immortal! It is Platonic. Christianity is a Greek religion. Christianity enculturated Hellenism and Plato's writings formed Hellenism.

W.LindsayWheeler said...

Again this is faulty: morality means:

1) Fair play among human beings.

We are NOT "human beings". Ontop of the genera "human beings" is race. The idea of "fairness" does not operate between races so that statement is very very decieving. It is actually quite harmful if that does occur because humans act in herds. I point to Christ's interaction with the Syro-Phonecian woman who wanted Christ to heal her child. Christ first refused. Christ was not fair.

Again what is missing from this chapter is also the mention of Virtue. "Fairness" is a doctrine of Cultural Marxism.

ozero91 said...

"Well, you are not.

If you like, I can tell you how you got created.

Just do a google search on 'human reproduction'."

We're talking about metaphysical, existential purposes and final causes, not merely biological, efficient causes.

B. Prokop said...


Since we've been quoting scripture on this thread, I might recommend the following to you:

"Do not throw your pearls before [trolls], lest they trample them under foot and turn to attack you." (Matthew 7:6, slightly altered)

These guys don't want a discussion - they just want to spout.

ozero91 said...

Just can't help it sometimes, but you are right. I guess I need to trust that the silent readers of the blog can sort things out for themselves.

unkleE said...

G'day Bob,


If you don't care for John 5:28-29, how about Mark 12:24-27? Or all of First Corinthians Chapter 15?

I'm not sure what you are getting at Bob? Both these passages teach resurrection. not immortality, which is the point I was making.

Do you think otherwise?

B. Prokop said...

I guess to me resurrection goes hand-in-hand with immortality. Otherwise, what's the point?

Even people who believe in reincarnation do not refer to what happens as "resurrection".

Plus (arguing from Scripture here) there are an awful lot of references to "eternal" life and a liberal use of the word "eternal".

I guess, to answer your question, I do think otherwise. Are you saying that the resurrected saints get to die again? Where does that idea come from?

Unknown said...

If you are planning to visit India, so don't forget to visit their capital New Delhi, and book Delhi escorts while your tour in capital. India is known for beautiful girls everywhere in all regions specially in Delhi

Unknown said...

Hello, I would like to thank you for sharing this useful material. The information you have mentioned here will be useful. I would like to share with you all one useful source which might be interesting for you as well.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for writing this informative content, keep sharing.

Texas CRM software is designed to target specific business processes and needs. SalezShark
Experts adopt a business-first approach to create a user-friendly Customer Relations Management System. This involves understanding the company's operations and pain points.

kinglalisah said...

Are you looking for the one of the best and affordable assignment help services highest educated writers on assignments? Do not tense your search is now end. always is there for help our customers because we know that our responsibilities. We involve more than 5000 experts specializing in different fields from different subject’s background. Also we pay close attention to the points that will help you fetch more and more marks. is constantly providing the cheapest and reliable Assignment Help Melbourne, essay help service, homework help service and dissertation & thesis writing service across the world. You can order right now and enjoy the benefits of our exceptional academic papers, Assignment Help Brisbane. If you’re ready to make an informed choice, browse through the reviews we have available.

bansal tirkey said...

We provide the best Escorts Service in Connaught Place. We offer our services each time with a new kind of posing and postures. Sexual pleasure with me is a matter of great exploration. Looking for the best Escorts Service in Connaught PlacePlace? What you do is up to you! Escorts Service in Connaught Place provides each possibility to discover the frame of an attractive and appealing young girl. Foreplay is the largest fun worried in lovemaking. Expert Escorts Service in Connaught Place are smooth to discover as you could search it at the net similar to you searched this blog. you can contact the individual by using calling or emailing. you will be given a date on that you want to meet the companion. our policy and practice has been that we would work with the elite Female Escorts in Connaught Place Delhi, and we hate mediocrity of all types. Scrutinize through locate the most smoking blasting Escorts Service in Connaught Place to have significant minutes with who are ever arranged to offer you the most complex Escorts Service in Connaught Place you will ever discover.

bansal tirkey said...

About Model in Connaught Place can be known to each individual how adores Call Girls in Connaught Place. Our agency has enormous number of clients domestically and globally. We are slammed in Different urban areas of Call Girls in Connaught Place. Because of the notoriety of our agency we have the best Model and Celebrity escorts in Connaught Place. We give 100% Privacy to our clients and model escorts. As the best Call Girls in Connaught Place, we generally plan a paramount night for our customers.Our agency is welcoming you to enter the universe of imagination by booking one of our delightful Call Girls in Connaught Place. Our staff guarantees that our shocking girls are exceptionally versatile to a wide range of circumstances. If you are not prepared to find a trustworthy one you should avoid utilizing Call Girls in Connaught Place from a certified or adulterated association. Possibly getting abused, smother your longings of sexual pleasure. Have a Party with Escorts in Connaught Place? Have no one to go with? No problem! Call Girls in Connaught Place is very well trained.

Henshaw said...

I have just read this blog and I’ll surely come back for more posts, and also this article gives the light in which we can observe the reality of the topic. Thanks for this nice article! Now read this too... betking kenya registration

Daily Word said...

Fantastic blog with excellent and valuable content. I just added your blog to my bookmark list. Thank for sharing. Overwatch Ranks

Jamie Starr said...

Great post, Thank you for sharing this amazing post, I really appreciate your work You may want to check out auction sites like ebay

Jamie Starr said...

I found so many exciting matters in this particular content, I would like to request please keep posting such informative content. Check out my free car reviews

Unknown said...

In general, I agreed to pay for excel homework but in a short time. There were fears that the performers would not be able to cope, but they turned out to be unfounded. I successfully defended as "excellent"

Techsavvy said...

Wow, thanks I just got exactly what I wanted from your blog, thank you so much! You should check out our website for fathers day wishes from wife

Living at the Edge said...

Thank u for thi dangerius ideas u provided here. Lots of great and useful material i got here which I saved and would help me with all my questions-answers

Assignment help Ireland said...

Opt for our Assignment help Ireland to finish your assignments and submit them within the deadline. No need to take the stress of insufficient knowledge and lack of skills when you have an online assignment writing expert for writing your assignment in Ireland.

WORKER said...

Great Article, it is really informative and innovative. africa small grants 2021

zingerart said...

Searching for the best wedding gift ideas? Here we can help you with ideas for best wedding gifts for couples so you can buy wedding gifts online and invest the time saved into shopping, may be? Here you can get help to choose unique gifts, also you can avail online wedding gifts in India. Wedding gifts for bride & groom are a best way to surprise them and wish them for a blissful life ahead.

S.Ram said...

This is Nick Jones working as a cyber threat monitoring engineer in Telecom Managed Services company for the last 10 Years. With the help of managed service providers, telecom services are monitored around the clock, meaning all customer experience issues can be noted quickly and resolved quickly.

Essien said...

Lovely effort; you ought to be a part of a contest for one of the highest quality website owner. I am going to highly recommend this website. I enjoyed surfing from The Three Parts of Morality. Thanks so much for sharing. visit evangel university admission list is out