If God did not exist, would the universe have stable laws. Minds prefer order, so we should expect stsble lsws if theism is true. But why doesn't the law of gravity quit on us ast some point? Since the laws are stable, doesn't that suggest a Bayesian argument for theism?
This is a blog to discuss philosophy, chess, politics, C. S. Lewis, or whatever it is that I'm in the mood to discuss.
Friday, June 14, 2024
Wednesday, June 12, 2024
From Facebbok
Monday, May 20, 2024
Lewis and Nagel
In Lewis’s essay “Meditation in
a Toolshed Lewis distinguishes between
looking ay and looking along. Looking at
is the third person scientific perspective, looking along is looking from the
first person perspective. This is the issue that is the subject of Thomas
Nagel’s famous “What it is Like to Be a Bat.” Many, from J. B. Watson to
Patricia Churchland, have argued the uselessness of introspection as
sub-scientific. Lewis, like Nagel, argues that this kind of dismissiveness
cannot be sustained, and he does sao on the grounds that to do so would undermine
the very reasoning process that grounds the scientific argument on which the
dismissal is based. He writes:
Having been
so often deceived by looking along, are we not well advised to trust only to
looking at? in fact to discount all these inside experiences? Well, no. There
are two fatal objections to discounting them all. And the first is this. You
discount them in order to think more accurately. But you can't think at all -
and therefore, of course, can't think accurately - if you have nothing to think
about. A physiologist, for example, can study pain and find out that it “is”
(whatever is means) such and such neural events. But the word pain would have
no meaning for him unless he had “been inside” by actually suffering. If he had
never looked along pain he simply wouldn't know what he was looking at. The
very subject for his inquiries from outside exists for him only because he has,
at least once, been inside. This case is not likely to occur, because every man
has felt pain. But it is perfectly easy to go on all your life giving
explanations of religion, love, morality, honour, and the like, without having
been inside any of them. And if you do that, you are simply playing with
counters. You go on explaining a thing without knowing what it is. That is why
a great deal of contemporary thought is, strictly speaking, thought about
nothing - all the apparatus of thought busily working in a vacuum. The other
objection is this: let us go back to the toolshed. I might have discounted what
I saw when looking along the beam (i.e., the leaves moving and the sun) on the
ground that it was “really only a strip of dusty light in a dark shed”. That
is, I might have set up as “true” my “side vision” of the beam. But then that
side vision is itself an instance of the activity we call seeing. And this new
instance could also be looked at from outside. I could allow a scientist to
tell me that what seemed to be a beam of light in a shed was “really only an
agitation of my own optic nerves”. And that would be just as good (or as bad) a
bit of debunking as the previous one. The picture of the beam in the toolshed
would now have to be discounted just as the previous picture of the trees and
the sun had been discounted. And then, where are you? In other words, you can
step outside one experience only by stepping inside another. Therefore, if all
inside experiences are misleading, we are always misled. The cerebral
physiologist may say, if he chooses, that the mathematician's thought is “only”
tiny physical movements of the grey matter. But then what about the cerebral
physiologist's own thought at that very moment? A second physiologist, looking
at it, could pronounce it also to be only tiny physical movements in the first
physiologist's skull. Where is the rot to end? The answer is that we must never
allow the rot to begin. We must, on pain of idiocy, deny from the very outset
the idea that looking at is, by its own nature, intrinsically truer or better
than looking along. One must look both along and at everything. In particular
cases we shall find reason for regarding the one or the other vision as
inferior. Thus the inside vision of rational thinking must be truer than the
outside vision which sees only movements of the grey matter; for if the outside
vision were the correct one all thought (including this thought itself) would
be valueless, and this is self-contradictory. You cannot have a proof that no
proofs matter. On the other hand, the inside vision of the savage's dance to
Nyonga may be found deceptive because we find reason to believe that crops and
babies are not really affected by it. In fact, we must take each case on its
merits. But we must start with no prejudice for or against either kind of
looking. We do not know in advance 3 whether the lover or the psychologist is
giving the more correct account of love, or whether both accounts are equally
correct in different ways, or whether both are equally wrong. We just have to
find out. But the period of brow-beating has got to end.t
.;
Saturday, April 13, 2024
Cause and effect
If determinism is true, the cause has to guarantee the effect. We often use the word "cause" to refer to things that influence,
but do not guarantee the effect, If determinism is true there are causes going back before you were born
that guarantee what you do now.
Tuesday, March 26, 2024
Tuesday, February 06, 2024
Thursday, February 01, 2024
Fallacy of composition?
1. Every molecule of the planet Saturn occupies space.
Monday, January 15, 2024
Thursday, January 04, 2024
Thursday, December 28, 2023
Melnyk on naturalism
Here's a quote by materialist Andrew Melnyk.
“Naturalism claims that nothing has a fundamentally purposeful explanation…Naturalism says that whenever an occurrence has a purposeful explanation, it has that explanation in virtue of certain nonpurposeful (e.g. merely causal) facts.”
Do you concur with this statement, or not? Do you think a materialist can, or should, reject this?
Thursday, December 21, 2023
Wednesday, December 13, 2023
Tuesday, December 12, 2023
Miraculous Healing: The case of Henrique Mecking
The great chess grandmaster from Brazil, Henrique Meckiing, was at death's door from a rare disease. He is alive and well at 71 todya, and attributes this to a divine healing when his disease was at its worst. A devout Roman Catholic in the charismatic movement, he had a rating of 2606 at the age of 60.
Does Jesus still heal? Here.
Monday, December 11, 2023
Virtue theory and humility
Aristotle thought that it was good to think highly of yourself, so long as you don't take it too far. The Christian traditiion says that humility is a virtue and that pride is a sin. How does virtue theory deal with an issue like this?
Wednesday, November 29, 2023
From Lewis's the Poison ol Subjectivism
After studying his environment man has begun to study himself. Up to that point, he had assumed his own reason and through it seen all other things. Now, his own reason has become the object: it is as if we took out our eyes to look at them. Thus studied, his own reason appears to him as the epiphenomenona which accompanies chemical or electrical events in a cortex which is itself the by-product of a blind evolutionary process. His own logic, hitherto the king whom events in all possible worlds must obey, becomes merely subjective. There is no reason for supposing that it yields truth. As long as this dethronement refers only to the theoretical reason, it cannot be wholehearted. The scientist has to assume the validity of his own logic (in the stout old fashion of Plato or Spinoza) even in order to prove that it is merely subjective, and therefore he can only flirt with subjectivism. It is true that this flirtation sometimes goes pretty far. There are modern scientists, I am told, who have dropped the words truth and reality out of their vocabulary and who hold that the end of their work is not to know what is there but simply to get practical results. This is, no doubt, a bad symptom. But, in the main, subjectivism is such an uncomfortable yokefellow for research that the danger, in this quarter, is continually counteracted.
Saturday, November 25, 2023
C. S. Lewis's De Futilitate
This includes different forms of the argument from reason than found in Miracles. Anscombe's rebuttals don't apply to some of what we find here.
Friday, November 17, 2023
Sunday, November 12, 2023
Monday, October 30, 2023
User Illusion
Perhaps the idea of a mentalistic explanation requires some explanation. A moment ago I went out to get the mail. I believed that getting the mail would be a good thing, I know where the mailbox is, and so I fulfilled my intention to go out to the mailbox and get the mail. My actions had a purpose which I fulfilled. My feet moved, due to signals sent from my brain, but the ultimate reason why the atoms in my brain did what they did is that because they were directed by something possessing a purpose. Or, perhaps the atoms themselves had an inherent purpose. Something desired by some entity brought it about that the atoms moved the way they did.
But these types of explanations are
typically excluded from basic physics. In fact, not only purpose, but
intentionality or about-ness, normativity, and first-person perspective are
also excluded. The four fundamental forces
postulated by physics, gravity, electromagnetism, and the strong and weak
nuclear forces, are blind forces, which do not act for reasons. If gravity
operates on boulders falling in an avalanche, they will neither avoid my head
to spare my life nor strike me to punish my wickedness. No, the gravitational force has no mental life,
and genuinely physical particles have no mental life either. But what happens
at the mindless level of basic physics, according to materialism, determines what
goes on at all levels. It is true that physical events sometimes produce
results that an intentional agent would choose, indeed that is how natural selection
works. But in the final analysis, if materialism is true, it looks as if the
idea of intentions or purposes or desires or motives producing actions is bound
to be an illusion.