Keeping it germane

I would just like to point out that for the most part the discussion that developed in this discussion is not exactly germane to the point I was presenting. I was attempting to show how it is possible for Lewis to advocate the AFR while at the same time explaining how Bulverism (what in logic textbooks is called the ad hominem circumstantial argument) is a fallacy to be avoided. I was not there presenting a full-dress defense of the AFR.

If someone wants to address the actual issue, perhaps we can start a thread on this post.