Geoff Robinson wrote:
I had the opportunity to pose comments to Dawkins while he was in Philadelphiaon his book tour. I am a relatively well-read layman, but color me unimpressed. I pointed out several inconsistencies. Among which he chose to respond to the Argument from Reason. And, frankly, his response was pretty much "I'm not sure why this is a problem."
That's funny. Darwin could see a problem. How come Dawkins can't?
Incidentally, Bill has a good little report up (at the Cadre here) on Mr. D's interesting reply to an audience question about determinism and ethics--not unrelated to him running aground on certain variants of the AfR.
ReplyDeleteI wish we had the actual comment and reply. This tells us very little.
ReplyDeleteI guess I'm cranky tonight. :O